Blog
31
01
2016

Eat Burgers, Not Salad!

When faced with social occasions, and eating out at a cafe or restaurant, you are presented a plethora of food options, each as appealing as the next. You are on a ‘diet’, and want to make the best decision possible so that your waist line continues to shrink. But you may have been better off choosing a burger, not a salad…

Here is why…

Now before anyone get’s their nickers in a twist, let me tell you that I am not saying that burgers are healthier than salads or visa versa for that matter, and I’ll show you why.

Salads are often eaten synonymously with fat loss, health, fitness and everything in between. So while you may have the best of intentions when opting to choose a salad on the menu, you must be aware that it may in fact be hindering your fat loss efforts.

Whilst there is no need to have a brain aneurism about your nutritional plan and try to micromanage every single minute detail in your diet, you must understand that you are not exempt from the bounds of science; the calories you eat count and your gluten free, quinoa, feta and walnut salad is most likely full of them…

We have a tendency as a society to get sucked in to fitness and health buzz words such as raw, organic, alkaline, paleo, coconut oil and so forth, and what tends to happen when we label foods as ‘good’ and ‘bad’, ‘healthy’ or ‘unhealthy’ is that we forget the big picture – calories and macronutrients.

Back to the Salad VS Burger debate…

Here is a typical scenario…

You are eating out with friends and family and want to make a sensible, ‘healthy’ choice because you’re trying to get rid of some stubborn fat.

You browse the menu, and decide to choose a salad as opposed to a burger, because your conscience is telling you that the salad is a far ‘healthier’ option than the burger. Even though you would much prefer to eat a burger, you don’t because well, abs.

Unfortunately, you most likely made a poor decision as far as your abs are concerned…

I recently scoured several restaurants and selected a number of their salad and burger options and estimated the calories in both to compare which would be more beneficial for my fat loss efforts… 

Here are the results…

TYPICAL BURGER:

  • 1x Bun (200 Calories)
  • 1x Beef or Chicken Patty (170 calories)
  • 1x Slice of Cheese (100 Calories)
  • 2x Slice of tomato (40 Calories)
  • 2x Slices of lettuce (10 Calories)
  • 1x Piece of bacon (100 Calories)
  • Residual Cooking Oil (120 Calories)

TOTAL – 740 Calories

TYPICAL SALAD

  • 75g of chicken / beef / lamb (140 Calories)
  • 20g walnuts (165 Calories)
  • 1/2 cup Quinoa (120 calories)
  • 20g feta (75 calories)
  • 1 cup of lettuce / spinach (40 Calories
  • 1/4 cup cucumber (20 calories)
  • 50g sweet potato (40 Calories)
  • 1 tablespoon of olive oil (120 Calories)
  • 1-2 Tbsp of dressing (Italian) (80 Calories)

TOTAL – 820 Calories

Anybody surprised?

I wasn’t, but I guess that’s because I’ve been in the calorie and macronutrient tracking game for years, and see right through the BS of ‘healthy food’ options.

Yes, micronturients matter, and sure not all calories are equal, but a salad with that amount of nuts, seeds, oil and cheese is a bowl full of calories and fat. Nothing wrong with that if you are fitting it into an energy controlled diet, however unfortunately most individuals who choose a salad instead of a burger have little understanding of nutrition or physiology.

A salad will have far more phytonutrients, vitamins, minerals and fiber all contributing to it’s ‘health’ benefits, however if you are at a chronic energy surplus (eating more than your body burns), then you were probably better off getting the burger and enjoying the social occasion, rather than trying to restrict yourself and missing out.

As you can see, there are a number of what I refer to as ‘calorie killers’. Ingredients that turn, what could have been a really calorie controlled, ‘healthy’ meal, into a blow out. Typical high calorie ingredients include:

  1. Dressing.
  2. Nuts & Seeds.
  3. Oil.
  4. Avocado.
  5. Egg.
  6. Fatty Cuts of Meat.

Now before the paleo enthusiasts have their jimmy’s rustled, let me just state for the record that nuts, seeds, oils, avocado and fatty cuts of meat are indeed very nutritious, and when eaten within the confines of a calorie controlled, balanced diet, then let the inner cave man eat.

However, regardless of their nutritional benefits, the six items listed above are laden with calories. If your salad contains 3 or more of these ingredients, it is likely going to contribute to a large portion of your daily calorie and fat requirements. 

My recommendations are to opt for a salad if you are serious about your fat loss efforts and really want to be bang on with your targets. And there are a number of ways to make your salad a better choice than a burger. For example, you can: 

  • Ask to have the dressing and oil on the side; and
  • Remove 1 or more of the higher calorie ingredients.

It’s as simple as that. All of a sudden, your salad goes from 800 calories to 500, making it an obvious choice when compared to a burger.

So should you eat a burger or a salad when eating out?

Well, I can’t give you the answer, because you will need to learn how to make your own informed decisions, but neither option is better than the other if consumed within your calorie and macronutrient demands.

However, if you are out, want to enjoy a social occasion, and are faced with nit picky restaurants who refuse to change their menu, just get the burger, enjoy it and move on!

Coach Jacob

author: Jacob Schepis

Jacob Schepis is the director of JPS Health & Fitness and one of Melbourne's best personal trainers. As Head nutrition consultant and Strength and Conditioning coach at JPS Health & Fitness, Jacob has transformed hundreds of physiques with his no nonsense, evidence based approach to training and nutrition!

Comment
10
Proof burgers are better than salads | Tera News

[…] He did a nutrition analysis of several restaurant-style burgers compared to superfood salads, published on his blog. […]

Stuart

The raw numbers are one thing, but surely the composition of those calories makes it a slam dunk for the salad?

Salad: natural (largely monounsaturated and saturated, low levels of omega-6) fats, mixture of animal and plant based proteins, insoluble fibre, carbs are unprocessed with little to no sugars. Nutrient dense. The dressing might have a bit of processed vegetable oil or sugar in it, probably the biggest unknown there.

Burger: refined wheat-based carbs in the bun, added sugar in bun and sauces, high levels of PUFAs and some manufactured trans fats (plus solvents, bleaches, stabilisers, etc) in the cooking oil and in the plastic cheese that usually goes into a burger. Quite a lot of filler along with the nutritional content.

Not to mention that you’d still be pretty full 3 hours after that salad (which has quite a lot in it), whereas with the burger you’d be starting to get hungry again after your resulting sugar spike and then crash.

Bruhh

hahah bullshat

Judy

I NEVER HAVE the Walnuts, Olive Oil, Cheese, Quinoa, absolutely NO dressing (I hate it), so my salads are doing ok….luckily I like dry salads. For a bit of bite I put in purple onion or radish (we get long white hot radishes here now – they went out of fashion for a while there).

Ivana

And yet not all calories are equal. You could eat one of these salads and the extra fat will leave you satisfied for longer and you get all the extra micronutrients. Or you could eat a burger, miss out on the micronutrienta and end up starving a few hours later. Also depending what ingredients are used, you have to think of the insuline spike, etc.

Proof burgers are better than salads - Australia news,World News, Politics, Economics, Entertainment,Sport,Business & Finance | Australia news,World News, Politics, Economics, Entertainment,Sport,Business & Finance

[…] He did a nourishment research of several restaurant-style burgers compared to superfood salads, published on his blog. […]

Salad over a burger won’t shift weight says Melbourne PT | Bingo Byte

[…] Here, Jacob shares his advice.  […]

A burger could be less caloric than your ‘superfood’ salad - Feeds van DiG.nl

[…] He did a nutrition analysis of several restaurant-style burgers compared to superfood salads, and published the results on his blog. […]

Salad over a burger won't shift weight says Melbourne PT - Social magazine | Social magazine

[…] Here, Jacob shares his advice.  […]

sabrina

Thanks to write this valuable post.The human body is amazing, so complicated yet so simple. Treat your body well, and it will reward you. Getting into a healthy and fit lifestyle is what most people strive for.

Leave a reply